View profile

Facebook Libra Series - part deux

Check out past issues of the newsletter along with more interesting crypto content as well as our rec

Satoshi&Co Daily Crypto Newsletter

June 19 · Issue #197 · View online
ZPX | Satoshi&Co Newsletters

Check out past issues of the newsletter along with more interesting crypto content as well as our recently-launched podcast series with leading crypto industry participants at our newly-launched website

Continuing on from where we left off yesterday, we continue to  explore facebook’s foray into crypto. Facebook’s ambitious launch of a global cryptocurrency can spark unprecedented broader adoption once it gets past initial execution and regulatory hurdles. For some more context, check out past posts here, here and here.
Today we look at the design, incentive structure and economics of the Libra coin, specifically nodes within Libra Coin.
Libra Token Design:
Libra is designed to be relatively stable in value (like a stablecoin). The value of Libra is not pegged to any one fiat currency, but to a basket of currencies (USD, GBP, Euro). Libra’s price will essentially be determined by market participants. As each Libra token will be backed by an equivalent amount of fiat money, the price of Libra is expected to closely track the value of fiat that backs the token. ‘Authorized resellers’ for Libra token can capture price discrepancies by buying and selling the Libra tokens depending on whether the price is higher or lower than the fair value. Libra tokens will have floating exchange rates against various fiat currencies, including the US dollar, and is expected to challenge the monopoly that the USD especially has as the default currency for global settlement. In addition to the ongoing tussles with regulators over data and privacy concerns, the launch of a new global currency will probably receive a lot of pushback from the US government, as well as other central banks, like the French.
Decentralization and Censorship Resistance:
Decentralization is the foundational tenet of Distributed Ledger Technology (DLT), Facebook has traded off decentralization for oligarchy, bringing onboard a clutch of major corporations, including payment giants (Mastercard and Visa), Valley majors (Uber, Spotify, ebay) and even a VC (A16Z). These initial Libra Association members are incentivized to driving users towards using Libra as their primary mode of payment. With Uber, Spotify, Visa, eBay, etc. as Libra Association members, they are heavily incentivized to offer rebates and discounts to users who use Libra to pay for a product/service. More on how these companies will eventually benefit from Libra’s growth as MoE (medium of exchange) will be explored in the following sections.
In a bid to perhaps appease crypto idealists, Facebook has left the Libra protocol layer open for developing applications that do not need KYC/AML checks, but users of proprietary applications such as Calibra wallet will require users to undergo KYC checks and comply with local regulations before they can use them. This definitely provides app developers a third option, other than App Store and Play Store, but the developers could be directly competing with Facebook for building applications on top of Libra. So, good luck with that!
One outcome of this effort, should it become a success, would be that Facebook would have managed to launch a parallel financial system to its users by leveraging the anonymized payments data on the blockchain. And this will end up supplanting or bypassing institutions that we take for granted today, such as banks, the SWIFT network, central banks’ hegemony on monetary policy etc. This is of course the crypto-maximalist view!
Source: Libra
Source: Libra
Two observations here on the initial list of 27 partners in the image above.
  1. No banks. The one group that is probably slightly less popular than Facebook in the public conscience, at least as portrayed by mainstream media
  2. Picture above is worth a thousand words. Or many millions of corporate lobbying dollars across geographies, to influence policies
Libra Investment Token:
Unlike the Libra token, which is practically available to everyone who can buy it, the Libra investment token is a security token issued to members of the consortia that governs the Libra blockchain and other accredited investors.
The opportunity to become a validator node and buy the Libra Investment Token is compelling, even if it is essentially a highly illiquid risk-on trade. USD 10m is the cost of a seat at the table that gets you a vote to influence future governance and policy, and another USD 280k is needed to actually exercise this vote. The payoffs, assuming one gets past the initial teething troubles, and the fairly onerous regulatory battles in various jurisdictions that will doubtless ensue, are pretty attractive. It is essentially the familiar stablecoin business model - every Libra token issued has to be mapped into a real fiat currency or equivalent treasury security held in reserve (Libra Reserve), and the interest on this float, which increases linearly with every Libra token issued is distributed among the Libra Association members.
One of the advantages of becoming a member of the highly-valued consortia is that these companies can offer an alternative mode of low-cost payment to their users in the form of Libra tokens and eliminate the high-fees that these companies pay to payment processors. Moreover, using Libra tokens these companies can tap into the significant user base of individuals without access to credit cards and offer them services that would be hard to offer otherwise.
There really is no cap to the stream of dividend income that these members receive if Libra grows exponentially, so there is going to be a fair bit of demand for membership into the Libra Association. There is a fairly detailed list of criteria, to ensure not anyone with USD 10m can just show up and become a validator. The highly selective criteria for becoming a holder of the investment token means that it is only available to high-value corporations with large user bases and investment funds with more than a billion dollars under management. The list is fuzzy enough to accommodate at least a cursory nod to decentralization and to let folks like this crew for instance, that is crowdfunding capital to bid for a node!
Unlike DAI, which is a decentralized stablecoin, Libra is therefore an attempt at creating a stablecoin using a DPOS-like design. You pay up to become a node, you are incentivized to grow the network, and you get rewards (interest income) with no real upside cap if the networks grows exponentially, proportional to your buy-in.
Source: Satoshi&Co
Source: Satoshi&Co
Effectively even if every FB user holds an average of one Libra token, which is a fairly conservative estimate, the yield is pretty lucrative at an annual 4.5%, in addition to the actual benefits of smoother payments and more customers that these businesses get.
If you have a network that you have access to, it is almost a no-brainer that you will want to launch your own coin, mint your own currency. Most ICOs were about raising capital, building a network by attracting users and driving up the value of the network, and of the coin minted to be the currency of the network. Of course, you kept a fair share of the tokens for yourselves and thus capture value. In the case of FB, they have the network effects in place, they have the capital, and they also have the talent. It was always going to be a question of when rather than if, with their coin. Given the flak they are receiving around using user data for advertising, creating a currency that can potentially be the currency for interactions across a vast swathe of humanity is completely in line with Facebook’s ambitions to be the infrastructure, rather than a player that uses the infrastructure. It is not going to be a binary outcome in the near term or even the medium term. It is going to be a fairly drawn out process with pushing and pulling and shifting consumer and partner loyalties and varying regulatory regimes, echoing how things are evolving in the broader crypto space. What is beyond doubt is that upon launch, this will truly unleash the potential of non-fiat currencies (including cryptocurrencies). So far crypto has been hamstrung by bad UI/UX, competing protocols and fragmented thinking. Its greatest strength has also been its greatest weakness. Facebook might just have opened up the era of network currencies! Expect other Valley majors to follow suit, either through organic or inorganic moves.
We will continue with the remaining themes in the next edition of this newsletter.
Meanwhile in Crypto Wonderland....
“Facebook’s Libra Is Already Facing Criticism”
A US lawmaker has said Facebook should delay the launch of its Libra crypto-currency - hours after the social network formally announced the project. Libra, set to be launched next year, will let people make payments via Facebook’s apps and WhatsApp. But the company should wait until the US Congress has examined the project, according to the chairwoman of the House Financial Services Committee. Facebook said it looked forward to responding to policymakers’ questions.
“Regulators To Discuss Crypto Regulation In the V20 Summit”
Cryptocurrency regulation will take a step forward during the upcoming V20 Summit where country representatives will assess the new course of legal action proposed by the international Financial Action Task Force (FATF). FATF will release proposals on June 21 in hopes of setting new international standards for crypto businesses. Legislators support the summit, which will also bring together national blockchain associations and the world’s leading Virtual Asset Service Providers (VASPs). FATF standards for blockchain and cryptocurrency have set high expectations among legislators. Of special interest is its impact on long-lasting financial security issues, a subject addressed by Japanese Congressman, Naokazu Takemoto.
“Russia To Adopt Crypto Legislation In Two Weeks”
Russia’s parliament, the State Duma, will adopt the country’s major crypto bill “On Digital Financial Assets” (DFA) in the next two weeks, according to a local senior finance official. The news was reported by Russian government-backed news agency TASS on June 19. Russia’s deputy finance minister, Alexei Moiseev, revealed that the State Duma is currently considering the DFA, and is expected to adopt the bill in the second reading within the next two weeks. Moiseev added that the authority has approved separate legislation for initial coin offerings, which will be a part of Russia’s law on crowdfunding.
“Liverpeer Raises $8 Million”
Video is the core entertainment medium of the web. Platforms like YouTube, Twitch, Netflix and more deliver millions of hours of videos to hungry consumers every day, and those deliveries will only intensify as video games move increasingly to streaming models. Yet, delivering all of that content remains an expensive and challenging endeavor. The largest platforms employ hundreds of video-encoding specialist engineers to optimize the transcoding and delivery costs of their product, while also paying millions either for their own cloud infrastructure or to AWS or Google Cloud. Livepeer  offers a decentralized platform for video encoding centered on the Ethereum network. Its early success has attracted the attention of media VCs, and the company announced today that it has raised an $8 million Series A venture capital round led by Northzone.
Tweet of the Day
Peter McCormack
- Declining users
- Too many ads
- Libra
- Zuck

- Growth
- Few ads
- Bitcoin and Lightning
- @jack
Today's Top Reads / Podcasts
Overnight Performance of Top 10 Currencies
You are getting this newsletter because you or someone in your organization signed up for this. You can find more stuff to read at our news and research portal, our crypto index token and our upcoming relayer.
Brought to you by Satoshi&Co
Brought to you by Satoshi&Co
This newsletter does not constitute an offering of securities in any jurisdiction. The contents of this note should not be construed as investment advice or as a recommendation to purchase securities. This note is intended for the consumption of the recipient alone and not for public distribution. Please consult a certified financial advisor or other appropriate practitioner as may be appropriate as per your jurisdiction.
ZPX Copyright © 2019
Did you enjoy this issue?
If you don't want these updates anymore, please unsubscribe here.
If you were forwarded this newsletter and you like it, you can subscribe here.
Powered by Revue
ZPX | 21-01, Clifford Center, Raffles Place, Singapore- 048621