🦉 10x curiosity - Process disasters - are we learn from them?





Subscribe to our newsletter

By subscribing, you agree with Revue’s Terms of Service and Privacy Policy and understand that 🦉 10x curiosity will receive your email address.


🦉 10x curiosity

April 2 · Issue #249 · View online

🦉 A weekly sample of links that made me think 🤔

Also published in 10x Curiosity
Learning the lessons of previous process disasters is an important goal for process engineers working in heavy industry. When dealing with high temperatures, pressures and volatile and often toxic substances things can go wrong quickly. It is important that the lessons of others are applied so that history doesn’t repeat. There are many informative sources of information online such as the US Chemical Safety Board or the Disaster Cast podcast.
One of the major industrial disasters in Australia was the 1998 explosion at Esso’s Longford facility in Victoria. There are many lessons that have been drawn from this disaster as a result of the scrutiny it received under the Royal Commission established to investigate it. Broadly the main lessons relevant to loss prevention are:
  • Safety Management System - incomplete implementation
  • Knowledge Stewardship - insufficient on old plant
  • Management of Change - organisational change not scrutinised
  • Audit and Review - inadequate attention to detail
A more detailed summary of Andrew Hopkins book “Lessons from Longford” can be found here and in this paper also by Hopkins:
  1. Operator error is not an adequate explanation for major accidents.
  2. Systematic hazard identification is vital for accident prevention.
  3. Auditing must be good enough to identify the bad news and ensure it gets to the top.
  4. Reliance on lost time injury data in major hazard industries is itself a major hazard.
  5. Good reporting systems must specify relevant warning signs. They must provide feedback to reporters and an opportunity for reporters to comment on feedback.
  6. Alarm systems must be carefully designed so that warnings of trouble do not get dismissed as normal (normalised).
  7. Senior management must accept responsibility for the management of hazardous processes.
  8. A safety case regime should apply to all major hazard facilities.
This Disaster Cast podcast focus’s in some detail on the accident with a slightly different perspective on the lessons that can be drawn from it.
A couple of other interesting items worth consideration through the various reports include:
Many of the lessons from Longford have been repeated in subsequent process industry disasters, notable the BP Texas City explosion. 

Piper Alpha Appleton BBC
Let me know what you think? I’d love your feedback. If you haven’t already then sign up for a weekly dose just like this.
Links that made me think...
The Power of Safety Leadership: Paul O'Neill, Safety and Alcoa - Aerossurance
The Red Queen Principle: Avoid Running Faster and Faster Only to Stay in the Same Place
Finding Your Innovation Sweet Spot
Check Out Copenhill, the Snow-Free Ski Hill and Climbing Wall Atop a Copenhagen Power Plant | Colossal
Did you enjoy this issue?
In order to unsubscribe, click here.
If you were forwarded this newsletter and you like it, you can subscribe here.
Powered by Revue