View profile

Steve's ITK: It's a dog's life


Steve's ITK

December 15 · Issue #7 · View online
Steve's In The Know: Everything I published recently, commentary you won't find elsewhere, write-ups of events I attended or spoke at, and industry rumours.

Debit card drone delivery
Opening thought: PR isn't broken
I’ve heard it said many times: PR is broken. I used to nod my head knowingly and agree. But then a few years ago I came to the realisation that PR isn’t broken, it actually works far too well.
Instead – although not always of course – it is journalism that is broken. The media routinely rewards the most flimsy of press releases with unchallenged and unfiltered coverage. This is particularly rife in the online, 24-7 trade press, where a slow news day is more often the norm.
My PR fluff radar went through the roof this week when I received a press release from Starling Bank, one of the UK’s crop of challenger banks aiming to re-define consumer banking for the digital age.
“Starling Bank to pilot debit card delivery by drone,” read the release, before detailing that the bank had tested different models of drone as well as the weight of Starling’s new debit cards and packaging (less than 1lbs, apparently), and that the product team were ready to take the tests to the next level.
“Plans to use the drones for the challenger bank’s official launch at the beginning of 2017 are now in discussion,” wrote the company. Note the words “in discussion”, but, regardless, so far, so good, you might say.
But then came the killer. Along with acknowledging that Starling will need to cross a few regulatory hurdles were this ever to be commercially tested, it is revealed that the drone delivery tests have all been short distance flights no further than 400ft, either indoors or within personal garden spaces.
In other words, if you happen to live next door to Starling Bank or whichever company it is using to issue its debit cards, you are fully debit card drone delivery-tested. And that’s without factoring in things like security. There’s a reason why banks often send credit/debit cards by signed delivery or to a local branch.
Unsurprisingly, I chose not to run the story, and instead sat back and watched which publications bit. I’m glad to say that no one in the tech media picked up on the press release (as far as I can see) but a number of financial trade publications did, almost verbatim. I’m not going to call them out – always stay classy – but I will share this comment posted by a reader of one publication because it perhaps sums it up best.
It must be a very slow news-day at [redacted] for you to run this sort of gratuitous clickbait. This is the sort of article that degrades the value of your reporting (which on the whole is excellent).
PR isn’t broken, journalism is.
Also, I mean no criticism towards the team at Starling, some of whom are regular readers of this newsletter. As I always say, great PR if you can get it!
Bonus: Which European challenger bank recently turned down an acquisition offer from an incumbent, something somebody was very keen to leak to the press?
Things I wrote this week
Revue makes email newsletters personal again
Knowmail scores $3.5M to apply AI to your in-box
Signal Media raises £5.8M to help companies monitor and sift through the news
Danish banking app Lunar Way raises €4.2M
Delivery Hero acquires Foodpanda as Rocket Internet shuffles online takeout pack once again
Closing thought: Hacks, cats and flacks
Journalists are known to be dogged but are we a dogist lot too, favouring cats over our canine friends? That was the accusation of a dog-loving technology flack this week, even though we both conceded that cats haz won the Internet.
Text message from a dog-loving PR
To help rebalance things a little and because I’ve had the flu all week and literally have nothing left of any value to add to the conversation, here’s a picture of a dog. Her name is Tikka and she hates tech.
That happy Friday feeling
Get in touch:
Want to continue the conversation? Just hit reply to this email or follow me on Twitter.
Also, please forward this newsletter to friends and colleagues who might enjoy it, and encourage them to subscribe.
Till next time,
Did you enjoy this issue?
If you don't want these updates anymore, please unsubscribe here
If you were forwarded this newsletter and you like it, you can subscribe here
Powered by Revue