Oct 1, 2020

Attribution in co-design

By Tyler Gindraux • Issue #11 • View online

Oh, hello! It’s nice to “see” you.

Text: This Week

I was watching Enola Holmes this past weekend, when I learned about the whole suing debacle that’s happening with Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s estate. Essentially, the estate is arguing that the Netflix movie (and Nancy Springer’s novels) take key elements from Doyle’s later books, namely, the fact that Sherlock “has emotions” and “respects women.” They’re suing for copyright infringement.

There’s a lot I could say about all of that. But, anyways.

This got me thinking about attribution. Leah Lockhart describes attribution as, “giving credit where credit is due throughout the process.” An interesting and, I think, essential, part of any co-design process. But what does that look like? How do we facilitate attribution well? And who decides what is safe, accurate or just? Let’s ponder.

Unlearning oppression in facilitation

[Attribution] steps beyond co-production or participatory design and aspires to shared control, shared accountability and more equally distributed benefits and harms of what we design…

I appreciate anyone who is learning in the open, as Leah seems to be, here. Reading this very much resonated with me, as someone who has shifted between a user research position in a large organization (anonymous! anonymous!) and a co-design practitioner thinking about the fuzzy origins of ideas. If you’re going to read one thing this week, let it be this?

leahlockhart.me • Share

Design is Human with Dr. Pierce Gordon

What makes you a good designer? Are you a designer if you’re an expert … or is everybody a designer?

In this podcast, Dr. Pierce Gordon – a researcher, facilitator, innovation catalyst, community builder – speaks with Elayne DeLeo about the very often overlooked innovation and design solutions created by oppressed and underserved communities since the beginning of time.

anchor.fm • Share

Open Design Now: Why Design Cannot Remain Exclusive

Open design is part of a shift from ‘wow design’ to ‘we design.’

Open design, a “form of co-creation,” is an interesting one when it comes to attribution. The open design philosophy poses an alternative to the era of copyright. So, as ideas become more open and shared, how do we manage the blurry chaos of attribution?

opendesignnow.org • Share

Loose ends | Reflex Design Collective (co-founded by Dr. Pierce Gordon), donate to Rock the Vote, 2° Earth and a singity song.

Text: "It is giving credit where credit is due throughout the process." Leah Lockhart

Thanks

I’d love to hear what you think? Any resources that unpack this a bit more? (Reply or find me on Twitter). Otherwise, see you all next week!

Did you enjoy this issue?

By Tyler Gindraux

This monthly newsletter is curated by Tyler Gindraux, a researcher and service designer based in London and Cape Town.

Design With encourages conversation while building a community of people who are interested in participatory approaches to urban planning, service design, and user research.

Tweet

Share

If you don't want these updates anymore, please unsubscribe here.

If you were forwarded this newsletter and you like it, you can subscribe here.