View profile

Another former Facebook employee sounds the alarm

Revue
 
Dipayan Ghosh once worked to improve Facebook from the inside. According to his biography at the New
 
January 24 · Issue #68 · View online
The Interface
Dipayan Ghosh once worked to improve Facebook from the inside. According to his biography at the New America Foundation, where he is now a fellow, Ghosh “helped lead strategic efforts to address public concerns around privacy and other issues.” He also “helped coordinate and develop the company’s public policy positions on matters related to privacy, telecommunications policy, and algorithmic ethics.”
Then came the US presidential election. Cecelia Kang and Daisuke Wakabayashi pick up the story in the New York Times:
As Mr. Ghosh, a former White House technology adviser to President Barack Obama, made the four-hour drive, troubling questions started nagging him. What if fake news on Facebook and other sites had an impact on voters? How did the campaigns and any outsiders use ads on the site to influence the election?
A few months later, Mr. Ghosh quit his job at Facebook, where he worked on privacy and public policy issues. On Tuesday, a Washington think tank, New America, and Harvard’s Shorenstein Center on Media, Politics and Public Policy published a report he co-wrote, asserting that technology behind digital advertising — the financial lifeblood of Facebook, Google and Twitter — has made disinformation campaigns more effective.
“The problems were much broader than we imagined, and it was not just about one tool or platform,” said Mr. Ghosh, who with his co-author, Ben Scott, worked on devising Mrs. Clinton’s tech policy platform. “It’s the profit model underlying the whole digital advertising system.”
I spent some time today reading the report: “Digital Deceit: The Technologies Behind Precision Propaganda on the Internet.” In it, Ghosh and his co-author argue that Russian interference in the 2016 election was the tip of a very large iceberg — and that everything is about to get worse. Here’s their thesis in one sentence:
“Political disinformation succeeds because it follows the structural logic, benefits from the products, and perfects the strategies of the broader digital advertising market.”
What to do about it? It’s tricky, they say, because under the First Amendment nearly all of it is legal. But they offer a few thoughts. Bolstering consumer privacy could help, they say — it starves disinformation campaigns of personalization data they need to be effective. (The flip side is that it could make legitimate digital ads less effective, too.) The authors also suggest regulations that encourage competition, which would result in smaller networks and make it difficult for disinformation campaigns to spread so quickly through entire populations.
None of it will be easy:
The simple fact that disinformation campaigns and legitimate advertising campaigns are effectively indistinguishable on leading internet platforms lies at the center of our challenge. They use the same technologies to influence people—reaching a share of the national market with targeted messages in ways that were inconceivable in any prior media form. But if the market continues to align the interests of the attention economy with the purposes of political disinformation, we will struggle to overcome it. 
Among former Facebook employees who have gone on to distance themselves from the company, Ghosh chooses his words more carefully than, say, Chamath Palihapitiya. But his report deserves at least as much attention. This is a serious effort to understand the systems that support our current information crisis — and one that lays out, in exhaustive detail, how Facebook has unwittingly come to serve as its foundation.
“The nature of this crisis in media and democracy requires an ambitious approach to reform from Silicon Valley C-Suites to Capitol Hill to the handsets of everyday internet users,” the authors write. “The American political resilience has through the ages hinged on our implicit commitment that markets must take a backseat to democracy.”

Democracy
An Inside Look At The Accounts Twitter Has Censored In Countries Around The World
Elsewhere
Why Twitter Let Noto Walk Away
Snapchat VP of Product Tom Conrad To Leave Company
Burger King made a surprisingly good ad about net neutrality
HQ, The World’s Most Popular Trivia App, Just Got Hacked by a Bot
A lobbying group for Amazon, Facebook and Google is kicking off a new diversity initiative thanks to pressure from Congress
We Are Truly Fucked: Everyone Is Making AI-Generated Fake Porn Now
Logan Paul returns to vlogging after ‘suicide forest’ controversy
Launches
YouTube Investing $5 Million in Creators Promoting ‘Empathy’
Speedy Neural Networks for Smart Auto-Cropping of Images
Takes
“This Is Serious”: Facebook Begins Its Downward Spiral
And finally ...
The Pope Just Said Fake News Is The Work Of The Devil
Talk to me
Questions? Comments? casey@theverge.com 
Did you enjoy this issue?
Thumbs up 1ae5a7bdfcd3220e2b376aa0c1607bc5edaba758e5dd83b482d03965219a220b Thumbs down e13779fa29e2935b47488fb8f82977fedcf689a0cc0cc3c19fa3c6bb14d1493b
If you don't want these updates anymore, please unsubscribe here
If you were forwarded this newsletter and you like it, you can subscribe here
Powered by Revue