View profile

Big Revolution - When smart paywalls are dumb

June 12 · Issue #107 · View online
Big Revolution
Greetings, for a second day, from a speeding train. It’s not the idea place to put together a newsletter, so I’m glad that tomorrow’s Big Revolution will be brought to you from my sofa.
– Martin.

Big things you need to know today
- Net neutrality is over in the USA. What does that mean? As The Verge explains, internet bills may start to look more like cable bills… in time.
- Bozoma Saint John, the high-profile marketing exec who left Apple for Uber one year ago, has now moved on again. It seems she didn’t fit into new-ish CEO Dara Khosrowshahi’s executive team refresh.
- Don’t expect to mine any bitcoin on your iPhone. Apple has banned cryptocurrency mining apps from the iOS App Store.
The big thought
The dreaded text-fade of a paywalled article.
The dreaded text-fade of a paywalled article.
When smart paywalls are dumb
Today, in an ideal world I’d recommend you read the FT’s in-depth look at why Sir Martin Sorrell left WPP. It’s a good read, but it’s paywalled.
Sharing paywalled articles in a newsletter is the ideal way to annoy your readers. At best it frustrates them that they can’t access the article you just told them they must read. At worst, it looks like you’re rubbing your privilege in their faces (“I’m a paid-up subscriber, and you’re not!”).
One piece of common courtesy is to flag paywalled links so readers don’t click through in vain. I try to do this, but it isn’t always simple – especially as paywalls are increasingly difficult to understand.
‘X number of free articles per month’ counters are common now, meaning the humble curator doesn’t know if their individual readers will be able to read the article or not.
And paywalls are getting smarter, too. The Wall Street Journal’s ‘bendy’ paywall behaves differently depending on a visitor’s behaviour. As Nieman Lab explained earlier this year, “Non-subscribers visiting now get a score, based on dozens of signals, that indicates how likely they’ll be to subscribe. The paywall tightens or loosens accordingly.”
And editors at individual publications may remove the paywall on certain articles for a limited time, based on how those articles are performing. I clicked through to the FT’s Sorrell article at one point in the day and hit the paywall. Later in the day, it was free for me to read. Why? I have no idea at all.
Leaky paywalls are nothing new. Google’s ‘first click free’ policy used to let you onto a site to read an article you searched for, and some paywalls have let clicks from social media in without charge for years, but now it’s harder than ever to predict whether sharing a link will result in frustration or satisfaction.
So, what should publishers do to help visitors understand how a share will behave? A set number of free articles per month is fine as a basic concession to non-subscribers, but I’m a big fan of The Information’s unique share links for individual aticles. 
As a subscriber, I can copy a special link that lets anyone I give it to read a specific article for free. Presumably, if I abused this by setting up a free version of the site full of my own share links, they’d be able to quickly shut me off.
In an ideal world, everyone would pay for everything they read. But that’s probably not feasible. So for now publishers, please share a thought for the humble curator.
One big read
Why the Future of Machine Learning is Tiny Why the Future of Machine Learning is Tiny
Here, Google’s Pete Warden writes up a version of the talk he gave at the CogX conference in London yesterday. It was my favourite talk of the day. 
“I’m convinced that machine learning can run on tiny, low-power chips, and that this combination will solve a massive number of problems we have no solutions for right now.”
One big tweet
For some reason, Twitter made a special emoji for the Trump-Kim summit. The reaction hasn’t been great…
Casey Newton
Trying to imagine a worse job in tech than designing a cute emoji to celebrate a murderous dictator
That’s all for today...
Like Big Revolution, please share this link with a friend and encourage them to subscribe.
Did you enjoy this issue?
If you don't want these updates anymore, please unsubscribe here.
If you were forwarded this newsletter and you like it, you can subscribe here.
Powered by Revue