View profile

Big Revolution - Don't give up on rethinking income

Welcome to Monday's Big Revolution newsletter. The sun is shining and I'm limbering up to have a prod
February 11 · Issue #344 · View online
Big Revolution
Welcome to Monday’s Big Revolution newsletter. The sun is shining and I’m limbering up to have a productive week. But first, let me share with you what’s been happening around the world…
– Martin from Big Revolution

Big things you need to know today
  • Google is testing augmented reality navigation in Maps. It’s intended for situations like getting your bearings after coming out of an underground railway station. The Wall Street Journal has a video of the feature in action.
The big thought
Credit: Anthony Abruzzo on Unsplash
Don’t give up on rethinking income
A test of a version of ‘basic income’ in Finland has failed, but don’t let that lead you to believe the idea of universal basic income is a flop.
Universal basic income (UBI) is the idea that society is better off giving everyone a regular payment of public money that is enough to fund a basic, healthy life. This would be instead of other benefit payments that are usually means tested, and everyone would get the same amount, whether they’re broke or a billionaire.
The concept has been presented by some as a solution if automation reduces demand for human labour.
The Finnish experiment was different. It was designed to give unemployed people a flat benefit payment instead of more administratively burdensome means-tested benefits. The goal was to see if it helped them find work better than the traditional benefits. It didn’t work.
This led a fellow of the neoliberal Adam Smith Institute to claim it proved UBI was a failure. Obviously, he missed the difference between what Finland was trying and true UBI, but it shows how UBI clashes with ultra-capitalist ideology.
I keep an open mind about UBI. I like the utopian idea of not needing to work, and automation bearing enough fruit for us all to live on. If we didn’t need to work, some of us would live a life of leisure, but some of us would pour our energies into new ways of providing value to the world that may be more impactful than we could achieve in a traditional job.
It might not work, but it’s worth trying and refining. After all, what we have right now certainly can’t be the pinnacle of human achievement when it comes to the way we live.
The whole point of UBI would be to support people in a world where there is less work available for humans, should that world emerge. And given the rise of zero-hour contracts and patchy gig-economy work, maybe that world is already here, just hidden in misleading employment figures?
One big read
Tim O'Reilly's argument against Reid Hoffman's "Blitzscaling" Tim O'Reilly's argument against Reid Hoffman's "Blitzscaling"
Tech legend Tim O'Reilly argues forcefully against the Silicon Valley idea that companies must be build fast and big, and designed to create monopolies.
One big tweet
YouTube recently said it would stop recommending conspiracy theory videos. That announcement got fresh attention over the weekend thanks to this Twitter thread, which explains how such unsavoury recommendations get promoted by the algorithm. Click through to read it all.
Guillaume Chaslot
YouTube announced they will stop recommending some conspiracy theories such as flat earth.

I worked on the AI that promoted them by the *billions*.

Here is why it’s a historic victory. Thread. 1/
10:17 PM - 9 Feb 2019
That’s all for today...
Back tomorrow with more. If you enjoyed this newsletter, please share it with a friend or colleague and encourage them to subscribe. You can send them this link.
Did you enjoy this issue?
Become a member for $5 per month
Don’t miss out on the other issues by Martin SFP Bryant
You can manage your subscription here
If you were forwarded this newsletter and you like it, you can subscribe here
Powered by Revue